The jobs market remains robust by all outward measures, but that is not translating into higher wages for most American workers, according to a report by the Ludwig Institute for Shared Economic Prosperity (LISEP).

LISEP issued its monthly True Rate of Unemployment (TRU) for September in conjunction with the third quarter True Weekly Earnings (TWE) report. TRU measures the functionally unemployed — the jobless, plus those seeking but unable to secure full-time employment paying above the poverty line. TWE is a measure of median weekly earnings after adjusting for inflation. Unlike the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) analysis, the entire labor force is considered in LISEP’s number, not just full-time earners.

“We are seeing increases in weekly earnings, which is good news, but these gains are in no way reflective of what we are seeing in the job market,” said LISEP Chair Gene Ludwig in a news report. “A competitive job market should bring more living-wage jobs. And that is simply not the case.”

Unemployment Numbers

Ludwig noted unemployment, as reported by the BLS, has been below 4% for the past seven quarters, yet the TWE is up only 1.7%. During the last streak of a sub-4% jobless rate — from Q2 2018 to Q4 2019 — wages rose more than 5%. Similarly, since October 2021, the TRU has been below 24% for the longest streak since 1995, the earliest year for which LISEP has data. Yet over this same period, TWE has only increased by 0.5%.

The Q3 TWE increased 1.1%, from $943 a week to $954, while the BLS reported an increase of 0.8%, from $1,110 to $1,118. The slow wage growth was consistent among all levels of income earners, with an increase of 0.3% (from $598 to $600) for the 25th percentile, 0.5% for the 75th percentile ($1,555 to $1,563) and 0.2% for the 90th percentile ($2,499 to $2,505).

From the employment standpoint, LISEP’s  September TRU stands at 22.8%, a meager 0.2 percentage point improvement over the August rate. Despite the overall improvement, the TRU for Hispanic workers jumped 0.8 percentage points, to 26% — an indication that more Hispanic workers are entering jobs paying less than a living wage. The TRU for Black workers improved slightly, dropping 0.3 percentage points, to 25.1%. The TRU for White workers saw the biggest improvement, with a 0.4 percentage point drop, to 21.5%. The gender gap has grown even wider, with a 0.7 percentage point improvement for men, while the female TRU remained unchanged at 27.4%.

“We applaud efforts to raise wages and create more living-wage jobs, but at the current rate, it will take generations for most working- and middle-class Americans to reach an acceptable standard of living,” Ludwig said. “I truly believe both sides of the political aisle are intent on some level of shared economic prosperity. Now is the time for action through sound, thoughtful economic policy based on real-world data.”

Source: Ludwig Institute for Shared Economic Prosperity